The majority of political scientists studying democratization in the third world avoid muslim countries due to the difficulty posed by islam. On wednesday may 14, 2008, at the marriot renaissance hotel in washington d. It focuses on his work about islam and the fundamentals of power, published in 1925. In this paper, dedicated to islam and democracy, we will give voice to the early islamic modernist, ali abderraziq4 and his view of islam and government. Negative labeling of political islam, therefore, should be ended. This book examine the perennial question of islam and democracy from an interesting angle.
Poll data show that significant percentages of muslims cite the importance of the role of islam in governance. The relationship between islam and democracy is strongly debated among the people who identify with the islamic resurgence in the late twentieth century and the beginning of the twentyfirst. Most scholars say no, and point to a mix of historical, cultural, economic, and political factorsand not islam as a religionto explain why democracy has failed to take root in many muslim. Islam and democracy explores the islamic sources beliefs and institutions relevant to the current debate over greater political participation and democratization. It then considers the socalled establishment view of the debate, which comes from western scholars whose writings reach a large audience by virtue of their dissemination by mainstream and influential newspapers, intellectual journals, and publishing houses. From a political perspective, however, islam seems to offer the worst prospects for liberal democracy. If we consider democracy as a system inspired by the universalism of values typical of the west, can this be compatible with the values professed by islam. Islam and democracy eliane ursula ettmueller abstract. The success of political islam, though varying in different muslim countries, depends largely on its advocates abilities to provide pragmatic solutions to real problems facing developing muslim countries. Political aspects of islam are derived from the quran, the sunnah the sayings and living habits of muhammad, muslim history, and elements of political movements outside islam traditional political concepts in islam include leadership by elected or selected successors to the prophet known as caliphs, imamate for shia.
Before we do this, let us quickly throw some light on the concepts of political islam and democracy, as well as, constitutional provisions for sharia in nigeria. Creating an islamic democracy although many muslims have favorable attitudes toward an inclusive political system, according to gallup polling, their ideas of selfdetermination do not require a separation of religion and the state. It focuses on seven exclusively nonarab case studies of relatively successful democracies in muslimmajority countries. The islam democracy discourse is one of those very interesting topics in political science that has been questioned by many scholars. The primary research question, however, is directed to uncovering relationships between political manifestations of islam and competitive, democratic politics and explaining how interpretations more. This could stunt political islams commitment to get involved in democracy, and in turn might open more paths to radicalization. Islam is not just a heavenly religion, it is also a religion to deal with humanitarian problems and seek to provide spiritual morality. This chapter examines the debate on the relationship between islam and democracy.
A general problem with the term political islam is that it tends to imply an illegitimate extension of the islamic tradition outside of the properly religious domain it has historically occupied hirschkind 1997. Democracy and islamic rule are both systems used to govern. Pseudodemocracy and the making of a malayislamic state in routledge handbook of southeast asian democratization 2015. Actually, the latter term is not equivalent to islamism in olivier roys terminology. Using comprehensive data on 17 asian countries from 1996 to 2010, the study demonstrates that religion is a significant factor for determining democracy. Brief apprehension of the historical and social background of abderraziqs reflections modern islamic political thought experienced a violent impact, which.
Islam remains a central cultural and sociopolitical force throughout the islamic world. Through some authors we have tried to understand if there can be compatibility and by virtue of this compatibility to establish a possible. There is, for example, the view held by some of the orientalists who have argued that islam as a religion is not hospitable to democracy, for islam refuses to legitimize political authority and encourages militancy. Islam and democracy a dynamic perspective japanese.
This paper proposes a short apprehension of the reflections of one of the most important progressive islamic scholars, the egyptian theologian ali abderraziq. There are, to be sure, numerous studies of political islam in the coun tries that will be. The islamdemocracy discourse is one of those very interesting topics in political science that has been questioned by many scholars. Islam and democracy download ebook pdf, epub, tuebl, mobi. The political economy of turkeys justice and development party.
In this article one wonders if the union between democracy and islam is possible and in what form. American policymakers and western governments would be wiser to promote the strengthening of. The asia program hosted three speakers to give their views on how islamic parties are expressing their convictions and winning adherents in indonesias stillyoung democracy. Political islam represents one aspect of the islamic revival that began in the 20th century, and not all forms of political activity by muslims are discussed under the rubric of political islam. This chapter outlines the relationship between islam and democracy from normative and philosophical viewpoints. It begins by tracing the historical roots of the debate. Thats been a strong debate about how the ideals of liberal democracy confront and sometimes clash with political islam. The term appears neither alone nor besides neofundamentalism or political islam. This study examines the relationship between islam and democracy with emphasis on the issue of whether and how islam has bearings on democratic adjustment speed. Belying assertions of the incompatibility of islam and democracy, many muslimmajority countries are now or have been democratic. The interaction of political islam with democracy arab american. Political islam and democracy in indonesia wilson center. At this point it is very important to examine the challenge that political islam poses to the establishment of democracy in egypt.
Some academic authors use the term islamism to describe the same phenomenon or use the two terms interchangeably. Islam is a faith whereas democracy is a political system. Islamists notions of democracy, in joel benin and joe stork eds, political islam. The explanation of why so many muslim countries are not democratic has more to do with historical, political, cultural, and economic factors than with religious. To do this, the study should give solid analysis and results. Article pdf available in japanese journal of political science 1703. Pdf islam and democracy a dynamic perspective researchgate. William liddle of ohio state university started out the discussion with an overview of political islam in indonesia since independence in 1945.
What do islamists and islamic movements want, and brought together a distinguished group of experts on the various aspects of this topic, including the relationship between religion and democracy, the muslim. Pdf this article examines the deeply contested approaches of political islam towards modern democracy in bangladesh, the third largest muslim. How political islam adapted to and changed indonesian. Political islam and democracy stars university of central florida. The term political islam is an academic concoction. Islam and democracy united states institute of peace. Unfortunately, even though in his later life his view about the compatibility between islamic political system and democracy was much more favorable and positive, what maududi articulated earlier as a philosophical rejection of secular western democracy has been perceived or upheld by many muslims and nonmuslims as rejection of democracy per. The rise of political islam in turkey angel rabasa, f. Yes, and one of the lessons of the arab spring period is that the existing state system had either been unwilling or unable to accommodate islamist political participation. A transitional government, led by a respected leader who is not shackled by a strong ideology and who can cultivate consensus and has wide public appeal, must take at least two years to allow secular and islamic parties to develop their political platforms and make the public fully aware of their socio. The relationship between islam, modernity and democracy is still greatly misunderstood. Pdf download islam and democracy free unquote books.
The success of political islam, though varying in different muslim countries. Majority rule and minority rights all democracies are systems in which citizens freely make political decisions by. Incorporating elements of the faith and practice in islam to political decisionmaking is a goal and virtue of islamism. American policymakers and western governments would be wiser to promote the strengthening of democratic institutions, rather than forcing new.
It works as an analytical umbrella under which political analysts club together various political tendencies that claim to be using muslim. Political islam and democracy in the muslim world by paul. To be drawn into an argument about any necessary incompatibility, or for that matter compatibility, between islam and democracy is to accept precisely the false premise that there is one true, traditionally established islamic answer to the question, and that this timeless islam rules. Esposito and voll use six case studiesalgeria, egypt, iran, malaysia, pakistan, and sudanto look at the diversity of. A basic value approach aljarhi, mabid inceif 1 july 2016. Islam and democracy it is election season in america and time to look at one the of the dhimmis favorite mythsthe democratization read more. Political islam designates a failed project in his works, whereas islamism denominates the new form of activist islam. They both have rules that are laws or practices that are expected to be followed. Using these two variables, political islam and democracy, this study will try to assess if it is possible to have democracy in an islam state. Shadi hamid, author of islamic exceptionalism, argues many muslims support a religiousdominated government, but that doesnt equal violence.
Paul kubicek draws on the experiences of those countries to explore the relationship between political manifestations of islam and democratic politics. Some of these islamists believe that democracy is a foreign concept that has been imposed by westernizers and secular reformers upon muslim societies. Politically islamic states having democracy and following democratic ideologies. The shortest and most encompassing definition of political islam is that it denotes islam used to a political end. Islamic values in politics, not political islam islam, in its original texts of the quran and hadith, did not introduce a comprehensive system of government. Islam prescribes its own political system, whose features resemble in many but not all aspects, modern democracy. Political islam and democracy in the muslim world lynne rienner. It becomes even more attractive when the compatibility of islam and democracy are examined under the rule of an.
978 1258 669 9 544 559 127 906 272 982 436 1275 668 1188 1232 402 169 1346 1394 1422 1484 235 1258 1049 1094 558 1254 8 1289 1020 140 1387 387 1549 220 762 1168 325 210 506 1343 591 147 955 1226 113